Subject: [Hipsec] New issue: Birthday check badly defined

From: [email-masked] (Pekka Nikander)
Date: Wed Dec 10 07:29:01 2003

While thinking about the lost R2 problem and reading
the -08 spec, I noticed that currently the Birthday
check is really only defined for R1.  Furthermore, the
I2 processing rules don't really consider the Birthday
check, it is only mentioned in the state machine.

This all needs to be clarified.  I still don't know
what is the "right" approach to this.

--Pekka