Subject: [Bier] Interim Virtual Minutes

From: Greg Shepherd <[email-masked]>
Date: Mon, 15 Dec 2014 09:14:03 -0800

Please read/review and send corrections or voice support so we can get this
posted ASAP.

Thanks,

Greg

-------

BIER Virtual Interim

Monday, Dec 15, 2014 0800-1000 PDT

Greg - show commitment going forward - what is form of commitment?
Ron - have list of drafts and dates they will be stable
Greg - are we on track?
Ron - looks good.
     need two dates - next rev and date we call it.

Alia: compelling problem statement not history lesson. what problem will it
solve that cannot already. what is the win?
commitment on draft. expectation going to experimental.
Andrew: Include use-cases in problem-statement?
Alia; not details of use cases - but BIER big wins. for example BIER
address scalability, so with BIER an SP can provide customers with more
features.
Greg: that implies problem statement references arch draft; that ok?
Alia: yes.

Greg - proposes standards track not experimental.
TonyP - agree
much hmmm-ing in favour

Eric - use the mailer more! ADs use to gauge activity. Transparent process.
Greg- agreed. be positive and not just negative.
Announce new docs to the list!

problem statement;
Author - Greg - confirmed
Andrew to contribute more.
next-revision - Jan 31.
Call for adoption Dallas
last-call Prague.

architecture;
Author; Ice
last-revision; 1/12 . version 02.
Call for adoption Dallas
last-call Prague.

Encaps;
Author; Ice, Erc - committed.
last-revision; 4/12 02 revision
Call for adoption Dallas
last-call 2015.

l3mvpn;
Author; Eric - committed.
Albert and Andrew to contribute of tracking.
Details need ironing out.
next revision before Dallas
Call for adoption Dallas
LC 2015

ospf;
Author; peter
next revision before Dallas
Call for adoption Dallas
LC 2015

isis;
Author; tony
next revision early Feb.
Call for adoption Dallas
LC 2015
Tony - adopt changes to [sub]domain in arch draft

uses-case:
Editor; Ice - Interim.
TonyP EVPN use case - Early Jan.
Albert LISP - early Jan
Andrew - highlight BIER advantages.
Ron - deployments and migration
Greg- most challenging and critical. Separate thread to move forward? Call
for new Editor
TonyP; OAM (mp2mp how?) VXLAN in DC.
Nagendra; OAM soon.
Ron; Traceroute.

new draft for deployment and migration.
Ice, Albert, Jeffery, Andrew, Greg
not to pollute the arch draft.
how to cope with multiple bit-mask sizes
how to mitigate non-BIER supporting routers.

compression drafts;
Author - Albert.
request for comments.

Charter Discussion
Authors - Greg, Eric, Andrew, Tony.
Reviewers - Ross, Wim.
first revision - end of Jan 2014.